Home/Talent visas
Compare the talent visas and green cards
Five paths, five kinds of proof. Laid side by side so you can see which one your record already supports.
| Path | What it gives you | What you have to prove | Employer needed | Self-petition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P-1A | Temporary work visa, athletes and teams | International recognition, plus 2 of 7 criteria | Yes, employer or agent | No |
| O-1A | Temporary work visa, business, science, education, athletics | 3 of 8 criteria, or one major international award | Yes, employer or agent | No |
| O-1B | Temporary work visa, the arts | 3 of 6 criteria, or a nomination for a major award | Yes, employer or agent | No |
| EB-1A | Permanent residence, extraordinary ability | 3 of 10 criteria, or one major international award | No | Yes |
| EB-2 NIW | Permanent residence, national interest | EB-2 eligibility, then all 3 Dhanasar prongs | No | Yes |
| TN | Work status, Canadian and Mexican professionals | A listed profession and the degree it requires | Yes, U.S. job offer | No |
Two things the counts hide. On the O-1 and EB-1 routes, meeting the number is only half the test: USCIS then weighs the whole record in a final merits determination, and a case can clear three criteria and still fail there. On the NIW there is no count at all, because all three prongs have to be met rather than any three of a list.
Which one first
Many clients file a work visa to get here and a green card petition on the same evidence later. Which order fits depends on whether you need to start work now and how far along your record is.
O-1 now, EB-1A later
The most common sequence we run. The O-1A or O-1B gets you working in months rather than years, and the evidence you assemble for it is most of what the EB-1A will want. You then spend the O-1 period adding the things the green card asks for and the work visa did not: more press, judging work, independent citations, a second award cycle.
Filing the immigrant petition does not put the O-1 at risk. An approved labor certification or a filed immigrant petition is not on its own a reason to deny an O-1 or an extension, which is what makes this sequence safe in a way it is not on some other visas.
NIW while you are still abroad
The EB-2 National Interest Waiver needs no employer and no job offer, so it can be filed before you have any U.S. connection at all. For people who are not in a hurry to move, or who have no sponsor in prospect, starting the green card from home and arriving on it is simpler than arriving on a work visa first.
The limit on that plan is the visa queue. For applicants charged to India or China the wait can be long enough that a work visa in parallel is the practical answer rather than the alternative.
When waiting is the better call
Sometimes the honest advice is not to file yet. A record six months away from being strong is better served by six months of building than by a petition now, because a denial sits in your history and the next officer reads it.
The signs we look for: criteria met only technically, by evidence that would not survive the final merits determination. Press that is all from one cycle. Letters that all come from people you have worked with. A contribution with no independent adoption behind it yet. In each of those cases we will tell you what is missing and roughly how long it takes to fix, rather than filing and hoping.
The TN exception
One sequence that needs care. TN status requires nonimmigrant intent, so pursuing permanent residence can affect your next renewal or entry. The pattern that works is usually a move to a dual-intent-tolerant status before the immigrant petition is filed, which is a decision to make in advance rather than at a border crossing.
Not sure you qualify? That's what the first conversation is for.
We'll review your record, tell you which path fits and what's missing, and say so if now isn't the right time to file.
Book a strategy session